Best Pizza in Peoria

Pizza in Peoria leans toward New York style, with a couple of wood fired Neapolitan kitchens mixed in. Original #1 Brothers Pizza serves NYC-style thin crust along with wings and subs, and has a 4.7 from 1,076 reviews. CHAR Pizzeria Napoletana bakes inventive Neapolitan pies from a wood fire in a strip mall, and Fabio On Fire | Pizzeria Italiana pairs wood fired pizza with pasta.

Plenty of the rest are family-run counters. Don's NY Pizza in Peoria makes a white pizza and garlic knots, and Ralph's Nino's Pizzeria is a mom and pop hole in the wall known for its crispy crust. Sports fans have Uncle Sam's, a no-frills pizza and sports bar, and Ballpark Pizza & Subs, which keeps games on TV.

Prices split between moderate and inexpensive, and many of these places have patios. Breakfast hunters can head to Best Breakfast in Peoria.

Best Pizza in Peoria

  1. Original #1 Brothers Pizza

    A basic spot serving NYC-style thin crust pizza, Original #1 Brothers Pizza in Peoria also sells wings, subs and Italian staples such as eggplant parm and meatball subs.

    • $$
    • Late night

    7440 W Cactus Rd # A15, Peoria

    (623) 486-4111
    4.7 Google rating 1,076 Google reviews
  2. Twisted Italian

    Twisted Italian is a casual Peoria eatery that mixes traditional and inventive Italian cooking that adds perogies, Italian beef and steak house dishes to the mix.

    • Italian
    • Seafood
    • Steakhouse
    • $$
    • Happy hour
    • Brunch

    9940 W Happy Valley Pkwy #1080, Peoria

    (623) 537-4000
    4.6 Google rating 1,223 Google reviews
  3. Fabio On Fire | Pizzeria Italiana

    Wood fired pizza and pasta in easygoing strip-mall surroundings are the lineup at Fabio On Fire | Pizzeria Italiana in Peoria.

    • Italian
    • $$
    • Patio
    • Reservations

    8275 W Lake Pleasant Pkwy #101, Peoria

    (623) 680-5385
    4.5 Google rating 1,370 Google reviews
  4. Don's NY Pizza in Peoria

    New York-style pizza is the draw at Don's NY Pizza in Peoria, a family-owned shop with a white pizza, garlic knots, wings, subs and an authentic Philly.

    • Wings
    • $
    • Late night
    • Reservations

    7539 W Peoria Ave, Peoria

    (623) 412-7828
    4.5 Google rating 1,167 Google reviews
  5. Ralph's Nino's Pizzeria

    A mom and pop hole in the wall in Peoria, Ralph's Nino's Pizzeria is known for its crispy crust, wings with wing sauce, pastrami pizza, fried zucchini and fried pickles, with cold beer and brownies.

    • Italian
    • $
    • Happy hour
    • Brunch

    9008 N 99th Ave #1, Peoria

    (623) 972-1993
    4.6 Google rating 781 Google reviews
  6. Uncle Sam's

    A patriotic theme and East Coast fare set Uncle Sam's apart as a no-frills pizza and sports bar in Peoria.

    • American
    • $
    • Happy hour
    • Patio

    18913 N 83rd Ave, Peoria

    (623) 362-3900
    4.1 Google rating 1,624 Google reviews
  7. CHAR Pizzeria Napoletana

    CHAR Pizzeria Napoletana is an unfussy strip-mall Italian restaurant in Peoria turning out inventive Neapolitan pies from a wood fire, plus salads.

    • $$
    • Happy hour
    • Patio

    25101 N Lake Pleasant Pkwy #1325, Peoria

    (623) 249-5366
    4.4 Google rating 926 Google reviews
  8. Ballpark Pizza & Subs

    A low-key strip-mall eatery in Peoria with sports on TV, Ballpark Pizza & Subs sells large slices, a 16in pepperoni pizza, NY style pizza, Philly cheese steaks, subs, sliders, calzones and boneless wings, with beer and wine.

    • American
    • Wings
    • $
    • Happy hour
    • Late night

    7615 W Thunderbird Rd Ste 101, Peoria

    (623) 979-8222
    4.7 Google rating 554 Google reviews
  9. CheezHeadz

    Everyday pizzas, hot subs and wings come out of CheezHeadz, a local family owned Peoria spot with booths and counter seating.

    • $
    • Happy hour
    • Late night

    20283 N Lake Pleasant Rd #110, Peoria

    (623) 566-6770
    4.7 Google rating 537 Google reviews
  10. Soprano's pizzeria

    Soprano's pizzeria is a small counter-serve shop in Peoria baking pies, with gyros, wings and other Italian staples beside them.

    • $

    6750 W Olive Ave #118, Peoria

    (623) 412-3372
    4.5 Google rating 610 Google reviews
  11. Grande Pizza

    New York-style pies, thin crust pizza, subs, wings and classic Italian dishes come from Grande Pizza, an enduring family-run mom and pop spot in Peoria.

    • Italian
    • $
    • Patio
    • Late night

    8996 W Union Hills Dr #105, Peoria

    (623) 566-5930
    4.6 Google rating 522 Google reviews
  12. Stevies Pizza Vistancia

    NY style pizza, white pizza and gluten free pizza share the menu at Stevies Pizza Vistancia in Peoria, along with calzones, subs, garlic knots, wings, chicken parmesan, a meatball sub and eggplant parm.

    • $
    • Patio

    28465 N Vistancia Blvd Ste B-103, Peoria

    (623) 388-6242
    4.3 Google rating 605 Google reviews
  13. Fuzzy’s Sports Grill

    Karaoke, poker, darts and covered patios give Fuzzy’s Sports Grill its character in Peoria, a sports bar that also has a pool table and a jukebox.

    • Tacos
    • $$
    • Happy hour
    • Patio

    8378 W Thunderbird Rd Ste 101, Peoria

    (623) 248-7172
    4.3 Google rating 538 Google reviews
  14. The Rec Pizza & Detroit Eats

    Detroit style deep dish pizza and Coney dogs bring a nostalgic Midwest feel to The Rec Pizza & Detroit Eats, a Peoria sports bar with arcade games.

    • American
    • $$
    • Patio
    • Vegan options

    20340 N Lake Pleasant Rd, Peoria

    (623) 328-9131
    4.6 Google rating 347 Google reviews
  15. Long Wong's Hot wings

    Honey BBQ, garlic parmesan and other flavorful wings, crispy and meaty, plus pizza and curly fries, come out of Long Wong's Hot wings in Peoria.

    • Wings
    • $$
    • Patio
    • Brunch

    8345 W Thunderbird Rd Ste B-105, Peoria

    (623) 322-3285
    4.4 Google rating 444 Google reviews
  16. Vinnys Italian Sports Grill

    A family friendly Italian sports grill in Peoria, Vinnys Italian Sports Grill has a pet friendly patio with 4 TVs and 13 TVs in all.

    • Italian
    • $$
    • Happy hour
    • Patio

    8267 W Lake Pleasant Pkwy, Peoria

    (623) 566-2233
    4.3 Google rating 428 Google reviews
  17. Mike's Pizza

    Mike's Pizza in Peoria sells slices and whole pies along with wings and subs, which also has a drive thru.

    • Wings
    • $$

    8520 W Peoria Ave, Peoria

    (623) 486-4807
    4.7 Google rating 243 Google reviews
  18. Modo Mio Italian Kitchen

    East Coast Italian-American fare has kept Modo Mio Italian Kitchen in Peoria in business for almost 40 years.

    • Italian
    • $$
    • Patio

    9815 W Happy Valley Rd #1100, Peoria

    (623) 572-5577
    4.5 Google rating 156 Google reviews
  19. Arizona Pizza Company Peoria

    Arizona Pizza Company Peoria is a quick-serve shop for pizza, wings, subs and salads, with weekday lunch specials, dine in, delivery and take out.

    • $

    16955 N 75th Ave, Peoria

    (623) 979-5134
    3.9 Google rating 80 Google reviews

Ratings and review counts from Google, November 2026. Ranked by rating weighted by review count.

All 116 restaurants in Peoria