Casual and inexpensive describes most of the 8 restaurants in Overgaard, with five of the places at the low price level. Pizza is the clearest thread, with GiGi’s Pizza and More and Pit Stop Pizza both here, alongside breakfast cafes, a barbecue spot, tacos and Thai food. Patio seating is offered by five places.
Breakfast is a strong suit. Wood Shed Cafe is a family restaurant with pancakes, omelets, biscuits and gravy and chicken fried steak, along with hash browns, a chorizo chimi and elk burgers, rated 4.5 from 542 reviews. Ponderosa Cafe is a family owned diner in Heber-Overgaard with biscuits and gravy, eggs Benedict, pancakes and a cinnamon roll, plus a kids menu, rated 4.7 from 230 reviews. Both serve brunch or breakfast, and neither takes reservations.
Red Onion Bar & Grill is known for steak dinners, prime rib, burgers, hand cut fries and a seasonal all you can eat salad and soup bar, with a green chili burger, a fish fry and a pool table. It has a dog-friendly patio, happy hour and reservations, and is rated 4.3 from 2,199 reviews, the largest review history on the page.
GiGi’s Pizza and More bakes pizza in a brick oven, with Wisconsin cheese and Boar's Head meats, plus wings, subs and pasta, rated 4.3 from 562 reviews. Pit Stop Pizza is family owned with a pool table and a NASCAR theme, serving thin crust and meat lovers pizza and calzones, rated 4.5 from 298 reviews. Bobby Deans Hickory Bar-b-q has smoked brisket, pork shoulder and half chicken with outdoor picnic tables, rated 4.6 from 51 reviews.
Sponsored in Overgaard
Best restaurants in Overgaard
-
Red Onion Bar & Grill
In the pines of Heber-Overgaard, Red Onion Bar & Grill is known for steak dinners, prime rib, burgers, hand cut fries and a seasonal all you can eat salad and soup bar.
- American
- $$
- Happy hour
- Patio
1931 AZ-260, Overgaard
(928) 535-44334.3 Google rating 2,199 Google reviews -
Wood Shed Cafe
Pancakes, omelets, biscuits and gravy and chicken fried steak lead the morning at Wood Shed Cafe, a family restaurant in Overgaard.
- Breakfast
- $
- Patio
- Brunch
2232 AZ-260, Overgaard
(928) 535-37004.5 Google rating 542 Google reviews -
GiGi’s Pizza and More
GiGi's Pizza and More in Overgaard bakes pizza in a brick oven and also offers wings, subs, salads and pasta, a family friendly spot using Wisconsin cheese and hand sliced Boar's Head meats.
- Pizza
- $$
- Happy hour
- Patio
2767 AZ-260, Overgaard
(928) 535-44454.3 Google rating 562 Google reviews -
Pit Stop Pizza
Pit Stop Pizza is a family owned pizza place in Overgaard with a pool table and a NASCAR theme.
- Pizza
- $
- Patio
- Vegan options
2232 AZ-260, Overgaard
(928) 535-57114.5 Google rating 298 Google reviews -
Ponderosa Cafe
Family owned and set in Heber-Overgaard, Ponderosa Cafe is a charming diner for breakfast and brunch, with biscuits and gravy, eggs Benedict, pancakes, hash browns, chicken fried steak and a cinnamon roll.
- American
- Breakfast
- $$
- Brunch
2935 AZ-260 b9, Overgaard
(928) 240-17064.7 Google rating 230 Google reviews -
Taquería Suárez
Street tacos, fish and shrimp tacos, rolled tacos and chimichangas make up the Mexican menu at Taquería Suárez, a fast food spot in Overgaard.
- Tacos
- $
2017 AZ-260, Overgaard
(928) 535-70584.6 Google rating 129 Google reviews -
KL's Asian Kitchen
Stir-fries, noodles and fresh sushi fill the menu at KL's Asian Kitchen, an Asian and Thai spot in Overgaard that suits takeout or delivery.
- Thai
- $
1945 AZ-260, Overgaard
(928) 535-80084.7 Google rating 63 Google reviews -
Bobby Deans Hickory Bar-b-q
Serving Arizona since 1995, Bobby Deans Hickory Bar-b-q is a barbecue spot in Overgaard that smokes brisket, pork shoulder, half chicken and spicy sausage.
- BBQ
- $
- Patio
- Reservations
2744 AZ-260, Overgaard
(928) 240-12384.6 Google rating 51 Google reviews
Ratings and review counts from Google, November 2026. Ranked by rating weighted by review count.
Catering is offered by GiGi’s Pizza and More, Pit Stop Pizza and Bobby Deans Hickory Bar-b-q, which suits a group gathering. Happy hour is available at Red Onion Bar & Grill and GiGi’s Pizza and More. Pit Stop Pizza also has vegan options, a useful detail on a page that is otherwise heavy on pizza, barbecue and breakfast plates.
Taquería Suárez serves street tacos, fish and shrimp tacos and a birria pizza, rated 4.6 from 129 reviews. KL's Asian Kitchen serves stir-fries, noodles and fresh sushi, suited to takeout or delivery, rated 4.7 from 63 reviews.
Heber is named in two descriptions, and the nearby city pages are Heber, Snowflake, Young, Show Low and Lakeside, for anyone wanting more choices beyond Overgaard.
Common questions about restaurants in Overgaard
Where can I get breakfast in Overgaard?
Wood Shed Cafe serves pancakes, omelets and biscuits and gravy, and is rated 4.5 from 542 reviews. Ponderosa Cafe serves eggs Benedict and pancakes, rated 4.7 from 230 reviews.
Which Overgaard places have pizza?
GiGi’s Pizza and More bakes brick oven pizza, with gluten free pizza available. Pit Stop Pizza serves thin crust and meat lovers pizza and has a patio area. Both cater, and GiGi’s takes reservations.
Is there a patio in Overgaard?
Red Onion Bar & Grill has a dog-friendly patio and happy hour. Wood Shed Cafe, GiGi’s Pizza and More, Pit Stop Pizza and Bobby Deans Hickory Bar-b-q also have outdoor seating.
Where can I find barbecue or tacos in Overgaard?
Bobby Deans Hickory Bar-b-q smokes brisket and pork shoulder and caters. Taquería Suárez serves street tacos, fish and shrimp tacos and a carne asada torta, rated 4.6 from 129 reviews.
Which nearby towns have their own restaurant pages?
Heber, Snowflake, Young, Show Low and Lakeside each have a page. Heber is also named in descriptions of places on this page.